1Department of Neurology, Changhua Christian Hospital, Changhua, Taiwan
2Department of Public Health, Chung Shan Medical University, Taichung, Taiwan
3Brain and Mind Centre, School of Medical Sciences, The University of Sydney, Camperdown, New South Wales, Australia
4Department of Electrical Engineering, National Changhua University of Education, Changhua, Taiwan
Copyright © 2024 The Korean Movement Disorder Society
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors have no financial conflicts of interest.
Funding Statement
SJGL is supported by an NHMRC Leadership Fellowship (#1195830).
Author Contributions
Conceptualization: Simon J G Lewis, Shey-Lin Wu. Data curation: Yen-Chung Chen, Wei-Sheng Wang. Formal analysis: Yen-Chung Chen, Wei- Sheng Wang. Funding acquisition: Simon J G Lewis. Investigation: Simon J G Lewis, Shey-Lin Wu, Yen-Chung Chen. Methodology: Yen-Chung Chen. Project administration: Simon J G Lewis, Shey-Lin Wu. Resources: all authors. Software: Yen-Chung Chen, Wei-Sheng Wang. Supervision: Simon J G Lewis, Shey-Lin Wu. Validation: Simon J G Lewis, Shey-Lin Wu. Visualization: Yen-Chung Chen. Writing—original draft: Yen-Chung Chen, Wei-Sheng Wang. Writing—review & editing: Simon J G Lewis, Shey-Lin Wu.
Study |
Behavioral and physiological alternations |
|
---|---|---|
Presentation | Significance | |
Sun et al., [151] 2019 | Sleep-awake behavior | Increased α-synuclein in CSF was noted in adults with chronic sleep apnea, supporting poor sleep may be related pathogenesis of Parkinson’s disease |
Jiang et al., [152] 2023 | Sleep-awake behavior | Poor PD sleepers have severe non-motor symptoms; in addition, the increase of nocturnal arousal may predict the progression of motor symptoms |
Brooks et al., [63] 2020 | Rest-activity rhythms | Continuous actigraphy can detect rest-activity disruption in PD, which is associated with motor severity and H&Y stage |
Obayashi et al., [64] 2021 | Rest-activity rhythms | PD patients exhibited a phase advance in circadian activity rhythm, along with amplitude reduction |
Vallelonga et al., [65] 2019 | Variations in cardiac rhythms or blood pressure | Patients with α-synucleinopathies showed a circadian rhythm disruption characterized by increased BP variability |
Shen et al., [153] 2022 | Variations in cardiac rhythms or blood pressure | 24-hour ambulatory BP monitoring is an important method to evaluate the BP alterations in PD |
Suzuki et al., [154] 2007 | Mood swings | PD patients with depression show an altered circadian rhythm in temperature |
Study |
Molecular alternations: clock genes expression from human/animals |
|
Gene/intervention | Phenotype | |
Lee et al., [155] 2010 | BMAL1 | Alternation in rhythm of locomotor activity, premature aging, risk factor of cancer |
Gu et al., [77] 2015 | BMAL1 | Tremor dominant subtype, contribution not only to circadian dysfunction but also PD pathogenesis |
DeBruyne et al., [156] 2007 | CLOCK | Circadian disruption presenting in locomotor activity and response to light |
Lou et al., [78] 2018 | CLOCK | An independent risk factor for motor fluctuations and sleep disturbance in PD |
Hua et al., [157] 2012 | CRY1 | Besides circadian disruption, more prone to depression |
Masubuchi et al., [158] 2005 | PER1 | Fail to adapt to environmental light-dark cycle |
Gu et al., [77] 2015 | PER1 | Postural instability subtype, also contribution to circadian dysfunction and PD pathogenesis |
Fu et al., [159] 2002 | PER2 | Caricadian control and tumor suppressor gene |
Lou et al., [160] 2017 | PER2 | Regulation of psycho-behavioral control, hormone secretion, mood, and sleep |
Study |
Molecular alternations: preclinical models from animals |
|
Gene/intervention | Phenotype | |
Tanaka et al., [161] 2012 | MPTP | Lengthen the circadian period of locomotor activity |
Hayashi et al., [104] 2013 | MPTP | Alterations of clock genes expression |
Choudhury and Daadi, [162] 2018 | MPTP | Experience PD-like motor and non-motor symptoms with circadian disruption |
Franke et al., [163] 2016 | MPTP | Prodromal stage PD symptoms |
Wang et al., [90] 2018 | 6-OHDA | Alterations of clock genes expression and antioxidant molecules |
Yang et al., [164] 2021 | 6-OHDA | Variations in circadian rhythms of blood pressure and body temperature |
Mattam and Jagota, [165] 2015 | Rotenone | Alterations of clock genes expression |
Valadas et al., [166] 2018 | PARK | Sleep fragmentation and circadian dysregulation |
Liu et al., [167] 2022 | LRRK2 | Lower clock gene expression and disrupted sleep-awake cycle with reduced REM, NREM and total sleep time |
McDowell et al., [168] 2014 | α-synuclein | Produce sleep disruption with increased NREM sleep, decreased REM sleep and altered oscillatory EEG activity |
Kudo et al., [169] 2011 | α-synuclein | The wheel-running activity shows reduced nighttime activity and increased fragmentation. |
Liu et al., [86] 2023 | α-synuclein | Disrupts biorhythms by destabilizing BMAL1 mRNA through miR-155. |
Langley et al., [170] 2021 | MitoPark | Display all-light- or all-dark-induced circadian rhythm dysfunction |
Taylor et al., [171] 2009 | VMAT2-Deficient Model | A shorter latency to behavioral sleep |
Potential therapy for CRD | Benefits | Drawbacks |
---|---|---|
Physical exercise (Schenkman et al., [172] 2018) | Improvement in motor symptoms | Concern of physical fitness |
Providing cardiovascular benefits as well | Fear and risks of falling | |
May arrest progression of PD | Musculoskeletal injuries | |
Melatonin supplement (Videnovic et al., [124] 2014) | Improvement in sleep and poor alertness | Possible side effects, such as, headache, nausea, dizziness, drowsiness |
Beneficial for the sleep-awake cycle | ||
Antioxidant activity | ||
Light therapy (Rutten et al., [173] 2012; Endo et al., [135] 2020) | Beneficial in non-motor symptoms, especially in sleep and mood disorder | Still lack of evidence in optimal light exposure, illumination and wavelength |
Simple and convenient | ||
Low cost | ||
No concern of drug adverse effect | ||
Potentials to restore circadian rhythm | ||
Small chemical modulators (Wang et al., [147] 2004; Hu et al., [148] 2015) | Alleviates behavioral impairment | Lack of evidence in human studies |
Neuroprotective effects of dopaminergic neuron | ||
Chronotherapy (Fifel and Videnovic, [118] 2019; Asadpoordezaki et al., [133] 2023) | To optimize medication effect | Difficult to propose a standard circadian schedule |
Low cost | ||
No concern of drug adverse effect | ||
Potentials to block the development of non-motor symptoms |
Comments on this article
Domain | Symptom | |
---|---|---|
Motor | Appendicular | Resting tremor |
Rigidity | ||
Bradykinesia | ||
Micrographia | ||
Dyskinesias | ||
Gait | Postural instability | |
Decreased arm swing | ||
Short step length | ||
Freezing of gait | ||
Oral | Hypophonia | |
Dysphagia | ||
Nonmotor | Psychiatric | Depression |
Anxiety | ||
Apathy | ||
Hallucination/delusion | ||
Dementia | ||
Obsessional disorder | ||
Sleep | Periodic limb movement in sleep | |
REM sleep behavior disorder | ||
Excessive daytime sleepiness | ||
Insomnia | ||
Vivid dreaming | ||
Autonomics | Orthostatic hypotension | |
Sexual dysfunction | ||
Bladder dysfunction | ||
Gastrointestinal | Constipation | |
Nausea/vomiting | ||
Dyspepsia | ||
Sensory | Hyposmia | |
Paraesthesia | ||
Pain | ||
Other | Fatigue | |
Weight loss Blurred vision |
Study | Behavioral and physiological alternations |
|
---|---|---|
Presentation | Significance | |
Sun et al., [151] 2019 | Sleep-awake behavior | Increased α-synuclein in CSF was noted in adults with chronic sleep apnea, supporting poor sleep may be related pathogenesis of Parkinson’s disease |
Jiang et al., [152] 2023 | Sleep-awake behavior | Poor PD sleepers have severe non-motor symptoms; in addition, the increase of nocturnal arousal may predict the progression of motor symptoms |
Brooks et al., [63] 2020 | Rest-activity rhythms | Continuous actigraphy can detect rest-activity disruption in PD, which is associated with motor severity and H&Y stage |
Obayashi et al., [64] 2021 | Rest-activity rhythms | PD patients exhibited a phase advance in circadian activity rhythm, along with amplitude reduction |
Vallelonga et al., [65] 2019 | Variations in cardiac rhythms or blood pressure | Patients with α-synucleinopathies showed a circadian rhythm disruption characterized by increased BP variability |
Shen et al., [153] 2022 | Variations in cardiac rhythms or blood pressure | 24-hour ambulatory BP monitoring is an important method to evaluate the BP alterations in PD |
Suzuki et al., [154] 2007 | Mood swings | PD patients with depression show an altered circadian rhythm in temperature |
Study | Molecular alternations: clock genes expression from human/animals |
|
Gene/intervention | Phenotype | |
Lee et al., [155] 2010 | BMAL1 | Alternation in rhythm of locomotor activity, premature aging, risk factor of cancer |
Gu et al., [77] 2015 | BMAL1 | Tremor dominant subtype, contribution not only to circadian dysfunction but also PD pathogenesis |
DeBruyne et al., [156] 2007 | CLOCK | Circadian disruption presenting in locomotor activity and response to light |
Lou et al., [78] 2018 | CLOCK | An independent risk factor for motor fluctuations and sleep disturbance in PD |
Hua et al., [157] 2012 | CRY1 | Besides circadian disruption, more prone to depression |
Masubuchi et al., [158] 2005 | PER1 | Fail to adapt to environmental light-dark cycle |
Gu et al., [77] 2015 | PER1 | Postural instability subtype, also contribution to circadian dysfunction and PD pathogenesis |
Fu et al., [159] 2002 | PER2 | Caricadian control and tumor suppressor gene |
Lou et al., [160] 2017 | PER2 | Regulation of psycho-behavioral control, hormone secretion, mood, and sleep |
Study | Molecular alternations: preclinical models from animals |
|
Gene/intervention | Phenotype | |
Tanaka et al., [161] 2012 | MPTP | Lengthen the circadian period of locomotor activity |
Hayashi et al., [104] 2013 | MPTP | Alterations of clock genes expression |
Choudhury and Daadi, [162] 2018 | MPTP | Experience PD-like motor and non-motor symptoms with circadian disruption |
Franke et al., [163] 2016 | MPTP | Prodromal stage PD symptoms |
Wang et al., [90] 2018 | 6-OHDA | Alterations of clock genes expression and antioxidant molecules |
Yang et al., [164] 2021 | 6-OHDA | Variations in circadian rhythms of blood pressure and body temperature |
Mattam and Jagota, [165] 2015 | Rotenone | Alterations of clock genes expression |
Valadas et al., [166] 2018 | PARK | Sleep fragmentation and circadian dysregulation |
Liu et al., [167] 2022 | LRRK2 | Lower clock gene expression and disrupted sleep-awake cycle with reduced REM, NREM and total sleep time |
McDowell et al., [168] 2014 | α-synuclein | Produce sleep disruption with increased NREM sleep, decreased REM sleep and altered oscillatory EEG activity |
Kudo et al., [169] 2011 | α-synuclein | The wheel-running activity shows reduced nighttime activity and increased fragmentation. |
Liu et al., [86] 2023 | α-synuclein | Disrupts biorhythms by destabilizing BMAL1 mRNA through miR-155. |
Langley et al., [170] 2021 | MitoPark | Display all-light- or all-dark-induced circadian rhythm dysfunction |
Taylor et al., [171] 2009 | VMAT2-Deficient Model | A shorter latency to behavioral sleep |
Potential therapy for CRD | Benefits | Drawbacks |
---|---|---|
Physical exercise (Schenkman et al., [172] 2018) | Improvement in motor symptoms | Concern of physical fitness |
Providing cardiovascular benefits as well | Fear and risks of falling | |
May arrest progression of PD | Musculoskeletal injuries | |
Melatonin supplement (Videnovic et al., [124] 2014) | Improvement in sleep and poor alertness | Possible side effects, such as, headache, nausea, dizziness, drowsiness |
Beneficial for the sleep-awake cycle | ||
Antioxidant activity | ||
Light therapy (Rutten et al., [173] 2012; Endo et al., [135] 2020) | Beneficial in non-motor symptoms, especially in sleep and mood disorder | Still lack of evidence in optimal light exposure, illumination and wavelength |
Simple and convenient | ||
Low cost | ||
No concern of drug adverse effect | ||
Potentials to restore circadian rhythm | ||
Small chemical modulators (Wang et al., [147] 2004; Hu et al., [148] 2015) | Alleviates behavioral impairment | Lack of evidence in human studies |
Neuroprotective effects of dopaminergic neuron | ||
Chronotherapy (Fifel and Videnovic, [118] 2019; Asadpoordezaki et al., [133] 2023) | To optimize medication effect | Difficult to propose a standard circadian schedule |
Low cost | ||
No concern of drug adverse effect | ||
Potentials to block the development of non-motor symptoms |
PD, Parkinson’s disease; BP, blood pressure; REM, rapid eye movement; NREM, non-rapid eye movement; EEG, electroencephalography.
Combinations may be more effective. CRD, circadian rhythm disruption; PD, Parkinson’s disease.