, Hani Taha Sherif Benamer3
, Georgios Kapsas2
, Rukmini Mridula4
, Rajesh Alugolu4
, Hasna Hussain2
, Afsal Nalarakettil2
, Sampath Kumar Natuva Sai5
, Mohamed Elmahdy6
, Rupam Borgohain4
, Kallol Ray Chaudhuri1,2
1King’s College London, Department of Neurosciences, Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience and Parkinson’s Foundation Center of Excellence, King’s College Hospital, London, United Kingdom
2Parkinson’s Center of Excellence, King’s College Hospital London-Dubai, United Arab Emirates
3College of Medicine, Mohammed Bin Rashid, University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
4Institute of Movement Disorders and Parkinson’s Center, City Neuro Center, Hyderabad, India
5Institute of Movement Disorders and Parkinson’s Center, Narayana Medical College and Postgraduate Center, Andhra Pradesh, India
6Bahrain Specialist Hospital, Manama, Bahrain
Copyright © 2025 The Korean Movement Disorder Society
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors have no financial conflicts of interest.
Funding Statement
None
Acknowledgments
We thank all the staff of Parkinson’s Centre of Excellence at King’s College Hospital London-Dubai and Department of Neurosciences, Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience and Parkinson’s Foundation Centre of Excellence at King’s College Hospital London for their cooperation and kind support throughout the research period.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization: Vinod Metta. Data curation: Vinod Metta, Afsal Nalarakettil, Kallol Ray Chaudhuri. Formal analysis: all authors. Investigation: Georgios Kapsas, Vinod Metta, Kallol Ray Chaudhuri. Methodology: Georgios Kapsas, Vinod Metta, Kallol Ray Chaudhuri. Project administration: Vinod Metta. Supervision: Kallol Ray Chaudhuri, Vinod Metta. Validation: Afsal Nalarakettil, Kallol Ray Chaudhuri, Hani Taha Sherif Benamer, Georgios Kapsas, Rukmini Mridul, Rajesh Alugolu, Hasna Hussain, Sampath Kumar Natuva Sai, Mohamed Elmahdy, Rupam Borgohain. Writing—original draft: Vinod Metta, Afsal Nalarakettil, Hasna Hussain, Kallol Ray Chaudhuri. Writing—review & editing: Vinod Metta, Afsal Nalarakettil, Hasna Hussain, Kallol Ray Chaudhuri.
| Author, year | Type of study | Design | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tröster et al., [86] 1999 | Prospective study | ET patients after thalamic stimulation | Unilateral thalamic DBS was associated with significant improvements in tremor and dominant-hand fine visuomotor coordination |
| Elias et al., [8] 2013 | An open-label, uncontrolled study | Unilateral VIM of the thalamus in 15 patients with severe, medication-refractory ET | In this pilot study, ET improved in 15 patients treated with MRgFUS thalamotomy. Large, randomized, controlled trials will be required to assess the procedure’s efficacy and safety |
| Lipsman et al., [9] 2013 | Prospective study | 4 patients with chronic and medication-resistant ET were treated with MRgFUS | Patients showed immediate and sustained improvements mean reduction in tremor score of the treated hand was 89·4% at 1 month and 81·3% at 3 months |
| Gallay et al., [31] 2016 | Prospective study | 21 consecutive patients suffering from chronic, therapy-resistant ET were treated with MRgFUS | The mean ETRS score for all patients was 57.6±13.2 at baseline and 25.8±17.6 at 1 year (n=10). The HF16 score reduction was 92% global tremor relief after CTT was 92% |
| Elias et al., [10] 2016 | Randomized prospective case control study | 76 patients with moderate-to-severe ET that had not responded to at least two trials of medical therapy and randomly assigned them in a 3:1 ratio to undergo unilateral FUS thalamotomy or a sham procedure | MRgFUS thalamotomy reduced hand tremor in patients with ET. Side effects included sensory and gait disturbances (Funded by InSightec and others; ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT01827904) |
| Hopfner et al., [26] 2016 | Observational-cross sectional study | 138 ET cases were diagnosed according to the tremor investigation group criteria and carried out assessments including Archimedes spirals rating, EQ-5D, Beck Depression Inventory and QUEST German version | A neuropathology consortium is suggested to standardize postmortem analyses and enhance the characterization of neuropathological findings, particularly in the cerebellum |
| Federau et al., [30] 2018 | Retrospective study | 8 patients with medication-refractory ET treated by amended to MRgFUS system at 3T | The correlations between thermal dose, lesion volume posttreatment and at 1 year, and outcomes after 1 year were very promising |
| Zaaroor et al., [40] 2018 | Prospective study | Patients with severe medication-resistant tremor who underwent unilateral VIM thalamotomy using MRgFUS | MRgFUS created a lesion at the planned target in all patients, resulting in cessation of tremor in the treated hand immediately following treatment, and UPDRS decreased (24.9±8.0 to 13.4±9.2) months after treatment |
| Kovács et al., [27] 2017 | 133 consecutive patients fulfilling the criteria for either definite or probable ET were enrolled | Patient-reported outcomes and self-completed questionnaires are crucial for patient assessments and clinical decision-making in both clinical practice and research. The study reports that the Hungarian version of the QUEST scale has satisfactory clinimetric properties, consistent with the original research | |
| Iacopino et al., [36] 2018 | Prospective study | Study of results of tcMRgFUS VIM thalamic ablation in a sample of patients with ET and with PD | All the ET and PD treated patients who completed the procedure showed an immediate amelioration of tremor severity, with no intra- or posttreatment severe permanent side effects |
| Chang et al., [28] 2018 | Randomized study | 76 patients with moderate-to-severe ET, who had not responded to at least two trials of medical therapy following unilateral thalamotomy | Mean hand tremor score at baseline improved by 55% at 6 months disability score at baseline improved by 64% at 6 months |
| Harary et al., [34] 2019 | Two controlled trials | Studies that evaluated DBS and MRgFUS for the unilateral treatment of refractory ET were compared | Both DBS- and MRgFUS-treated patients had significant tremor improvement that was sustained for 1-year and significant improvement in QOL. The MRgFUS cohort had higher rates of persistent neurologic AE, whereas the DBS group had higher rates of surgery- and hardware-related AEs, including intracranial haemorrhage |
| Halpern et al., [33] 2019 | A controlled multicenter prospective trial | 3-year follow-up of a controlled multicenter prospective trial | Measured scores remained improved from baseline to 36 months on CRST. Range of improvement from baseline was 38%–50% in hand tremor, 43%–56% in disability, 50%–75% in postural tremor, and 27%–42% in QOL |
| Park et al., [38] 2019 | Retrospective study | Intractable ET tremor patients treated with MRgFUS thalamotomy for ET | 4 years postoperatively, improvement of the hand tremor score was 56%, disability score was 63%, postural score was 70%, and action score was 63%. There was no permanent adverse effect throughout the 4-year follow-up period |
| Sinai et al., [39] 2020 | Prospective study | 44 ET patients treated with unilateral MRgFUS VIM thalamotomy over 5 years | Tremor was significantly improved immediately following MRgFUS in all patients. |
| CRST scores in the treated hand improved by a median of 23 at 5 years. QUEST scores showed significant improvement, with median change of 28 points at 5 years | |||
| Paschen et al., [87] 2019 | Prospective study | 20 patients with ET with DBS | VIM-DBS improved the TRS in the short term and long term significantly. Long-term worsening of the TRS was more profound during stim-ON than in the stim-OFF condition, indicating habituation to stimulation |
| Gallay et al., [61] 2020 | Prospective study | Unilateral MRgFUS on ten chronic therapy-resistant ET patients | Reduction in CRST score at 3 months. No bleeding or infection. No dysarthria |
| Martínez-Fernández et al., [54] 2020 | Retrospective study | 9 patients with refractory ET and previously treated with unilateral FUS thalamotomy at least 5 months before underwent bilateral treatment | 9 patients were treated. No permanent AEs. CRST score improved by 71%, reduction in head and voice tremor was 66% |
| Ito et al., [37] 2020 | Prospective study | 10 ET patients who underwent MRgFUS left-sided VIM thalamotomy | 60% decrease in the average CRST score of the right hand persisted until 2 years. CRST score of the left hand and the average QUEST score showed no improvement. Headache was the most common AE no delayed Aes |
| Iorio-Morin et al., [88] 2021 | Prospective, single-arm, single-blinded phase two trial of second-side magnetic resonance | Guided FUS thalamotomy in patients with ET | Improvement in QOL at 3 months. Tremor significantly improved in all patients |
| Fukutome et al., [84] 2022 | Retrospectively study | Study of efficacy and safety of staged bilateral VIM thalamotomy for refractory ET | Progressive reduction of CRST total scores from baseline to second postop review |
| Cosgrove et al., [29] 2023 | Prospective, controlled, multicenter clinical trial | The long-term safety and efficacy of unilateral MRgFUS thalamotomy for medication-refractory ET in a cohort of patients | CRST scores for postural tremor (Part A) for the treated hand remained significantly improved. Combined hand tremor/motor scores (Parts A and B) also improved by 49.5% and 40.4% |
| Kaplitt et al., [89] 2024 | Prospective, open-label study | Bilateral FUS thalmatomy on ET | Tremor/motor score improved from 17.4 to 6.4. Significant improvement in mean (SD) postural tremor and mean (SD) disability score 12 developed- ataxia, 6 persisted at 12 months |
| Hino et al., [35] 2024 | Retrospective study | Real-world data from 101 patients who underwent MRgFUS between July 2019 and March 2022 at a single institution were analyzed | MRgFUS significantly improved total CRST and tremor score across all SDR subgroups. Additionally, there were no significant differences in the improvement rates among the 4 subgroups |
| Saporito et al., [90] 2024 | Prospective evaluation | Cognitive and neurobehavioral profile of patients with ET or PD related tremor undergoing MRgFUS thalamotomy at 1 year-follow-up following the treatment | Significant improvement was detected at the 1 year-follow-up assessment in anxiety and mood feelings (Hamilton Anxiety rating scale); Beck depression Inventory II score |
MRgFUS, magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound; ET, essential tremor; DBS, deep brain stimulation; ETRS, essential tremor rating score; CCT, cerebellothalamic tractotomy; HF, hand function; FUS, focused ultrasound; EQ-5D, EuroQol-5 dimension; VIM, ventral intermediate nucleus; UPDRS, Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale; QUEST, Quality of Life in Essential Tremor Questionnaire; PD, Parkinson’s disease; QOL, quality of life; AE, adverse event; CRST, Clinical Rating Scale for Tremor; TRS, tremor rating scale; SD, standard deviation; SDR, skull density ratio.
| Author, year | Type of study | Design | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mitchell et al., [91] 1989 | Animal case control study | Induced generalized parkinsonism vs. unilateral parkinsonism studied on monkeys | The central importance of the STN in all three conditions is proposed, and supportive evidence for the excitatory nature of subthalamic efferent fibres is adduced |
| Bergman et al., [49] 1990 | Experimental animal study | Artificially induced parkinsonism studied on monkeys | Significant role of excessive activity in the STN in PD |
| Guridi et al., [50] 1996 | Experimental animal case control study | 9 monkeys treated with MPTP in which the STN was unilaterally lesioned by kainic acid injection | Significant role in role of STN hyperactivity in the pathophysiology of parkinsonism and may have surgical implications |
| Alvarez et al., [92] 2005 | Open label pilot study | Patients with staged subthalamotomy compared to 11 patients received bilateral simultaneous subthalamotomy | Bilateral subthalamotomy may induce a significant and long-lasting improvement of advanced PD |
| Alvarez et al., [51] 2009 | Prospective study | 89 patients with PD were treated with unilateral subthalamotomyand followed up | Unilateral subthalamotomy was associated with significant and sustained motor benefit |
| Na et al., [42] 2015 | Case report | Study of unilateral MRgFUS pallidotomy in a patient with PD | Unilateral MRgFUS controls levodopa-induced dyskinesia and cardinal motor symptoms |
| Schlesinger et al., [43] 2015 | Prospective study | 7 PD patients, with severe refractory tremor, underwent VIM thalamotomy using MRgFUS | Thalamotomy using MRgFUS is safe and effective in PD patients |
| Bond et al., [44] 2017 | Randomized controled study | 53 patients underwent FUS thalamotomy or a sham procedure at 2 centers from October18, 2012, to January 8, 2015 were studied | FUS thalamotomy for patients with TDPD demonstrated improvements in medication-refractory tremor by CRST assessments |
| Zaaroor et al., [40] 2018 | Prospective study | Patients with severe medication-resistant tremor who underwent unilateral VIM thalamotomy using MRgFUS | MRgFUS created a lesion at the planned target in all patients, resulting in significant relief of symptoms |
| Martínez-Fernández et al., [53] 2018 | Prospective, open-label pilot study | 10 patients with asymmetric parkinsonism underwent FUS unilateral subthalamotomy | MRgFUS unilateral subthalamotomy was well tolerated and improved motor features |
| Jung et al., [58] 2019 | Prospective, nonrandomized, single-arm clinical trial | 10 patients with medication-refractory, dyskinesia-dominant PD underwent unilateral MRgFUS pallidotomy using the Exablate 4,000 device | Demonstrated the efficacy of pallidal lesioning using MRgFUS and certain limitations that are unavoidably associated with incomplete thermal lesioning due to technical issues |
| Eisenberg et al., [59] 2021 | Multicentre open-label study | 20 patients with PD and L-dopa responsiveness, asymmetrical motor signs, and motor fluctuations, including dyskinesias, underwent unilateral MRgFUS ablation of the globus pallidus internus | MRgFUS pallidotomy is feasible and effective in the treatment of patients with PD and motor fluctuations, including dyskinesias |
| Polyakova et al., [48] 2020 | Experimental animal study | 2 male Japanese monkeys were studied for recording of STN neuronal activity was performed 2 or 3 d/week for several months | The STN, receives cortical inputs through the cortico-STN direct and cortico-striato-external pallido-STN indirect pathways |
| Martínez-Fernández et al., [54] 2020 | Randomized control study | 40 enrolled patients, 27 were assigned to FUS subthalamotomy (active treatment) and 13 to the sham procedure (control) | FUS subthalamotomy in one hemisphere improved motor features of PD |
| Gallay et al., [61] 2020 | Case series | 52 interventions in 47 patients | Significant reduction in UPDRS |
| Gallay et al., [23] 2021 | Prospective study | 10 patients suffering from chronic and therapy-resistant PD having received bilateral PTT were followed for 1 year after operation of the second side | UPDRS reduced by 52%. Gait and postural instability unchanged. Speech difficulties increased |
| Armengou Garcia et al., [55] 2021 | Prospective study | 14 patients underwent unilateral MRgFUS subthalamotomy were studied | MRgFUS is safe and that the benefits on PD motor features are similar to what was previously reported |
| Yamamoto et al., [46] 2021 | Prospective study | 1-year outcomes of VIM thalamotomy with FUS in patients with medication resistant TDPD | VIM-FUS thalamotomy can be safely and effectively used to treat patients with TDPD |
| Sinai et al., [41] 2022 | Retrospective study | Outcome of FUS thalamotomy in TDPD patients with 1–5 years of follow-up | CRST score, median UPDRS score, decreased significantly Adverse events were mild |
| Krishna et al., [60] 2023 | Randomized controlled study | 94 patients, 69 on active treatment were studied | Unilateral pallidal ultrasound ablation improved motor function or |
MRgFUS, magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound; PD, Parkinson’s disease; STN, subthalamic nucleus; MPTP, 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine; FUS, focused ultrasound; TDPD, tremor-dominant Parkinson’s disease; CRST, Clinical Rating Scale for Tremor; VIM, ventral intermediate nucleus; UPDRS, Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale.
Comments on this article
| Author, year | Type of study | Design | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tröster et al., [86] 1999 | Prospective study | ET patients after thalamic stimulation | Unilateral thalamic DBS was associated with significant improvements in tremor and dominant-hand fine visuomotor coordination |
| Elias et al., [8] 2013 | An open-label, uncontrolled study | Unilateral VIM of the thalamus in 15 patients with severe, medication-refractory ET | In this pilot study, ET improved in 15 patients treated with MRgFUS thalamotomy. Large, randomized, controlled trials will be required to assess the procedure’s efficacy and safety |
| Lipsman et al., [9] 2013 | Prospective study | 4 patients with chronic and medication-resistant ET were treated with MRgFUS | Patients showed immediate and sustained improvements mean reduction in tremor score of the treated hand was 89·4% at 1 month and 81·3% at 3 months |
| Gallay et al., [31] 2016 | Prospective study | 21 consecutive patients suffering from chronic, therapy-resistant ET were treated with MRgFUS | The mean ETRS score for all patients was 57.6±13.2 at baseline and 25.8±17.6 at 1 year (n=10). The HF16 score reduction was 92% global tremor relief after CTT was 92% |
| Elias et al., [10] 2016 | Randomized prospective case control study | 76 patients with moderate-to-severe ET that had not responded to at least two trials of medical therapy and randomly assigned them in a 3:1 ratio to undergo unilateral FUS thalamotomy or a sham procedure | MRgFUS thalamotomy reduced hand tremor in patients with ET. Side effects included sensory and gait disturbances (Funded by InSightec and others; ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT01827904) |
| Hopfner et al., [26] 2016 | Observational-cross sectional study | 138 ET cases were diagnosed according to the tremor investigation group criteria and carried out assessments including Archimedes spirals rating, EQ-5D, Beck Depression Inventory and QUEST German version | A neuropathology consortium is suggested to standardize postmortem analyses and enhance the characterization of neuropathological findings, particularly in the cerebellum |
| Federau et al., [30] 2018 | Retrospective study | 8 patients with medication-refractory ET treated by amended to MRgFUS system at 3T | The correlations between thermal dose, lesion volume posttreatment and at 1 year, and outcomes after 1 year were very promising |
| Zaaroor et al., [40] 2018 | Prospective study | Patients with severe medication-resistant tremor who underwent unilateral VIM thalamotomy using MRgFUS | MRgFUS created a lesion at the planned target in all patients, resulting in cessation of tremor in the treated hand immediately following treatment, and UPDRS decreased (24.9±8.0 to 13.4±9.2) months after treatment |
| Kovács et al., [27] 2017 | 133 consecutive patients fulfilling the criteria for either definite or probable ET were enrolled | Patient-reported outcomes and self-completed questionnaires are crucial for patient assessments and clinical decision-making in both clinical practice and research. The study reports that the Hungarian version of the QUEST scale has satisfactory clinimetric properties, consistent with the original research | |
| Iacopino et al., [36] 2018 | Prospective study | Study of results of tcMRgFUS VIM thalamic ablation in a sample of patients with ET and with PD | All the ET and PD treated patients who completed the procedure showed an immediate amelioration of tremor severity, with no intra- or posttreatment severe permanent side effects |
| Chang et al., [28] 2018 | Randomized study | 76 patients with moderate-to-severe ET, who had not responded to at least two trials of medical therapy following unilateral thalamotomy | Mean hand tremor score at baseline improved by 55% at 6 months disability score at baseline improved by 64% at 6 months |
| Harary et al., [34] 2019 | Two controlled trials | Studies that evaluated DBS and MRgFUS for the unilateral treatment of refractory ET were compared | Both DBS- and MRgFUS-treated patients had significant tremor improvement that was sustained for 1-year and significant improvement in QOL. The MRgFUS cohort had higher rates of persistent neurologic AE, whereas the DBS group had higher rates of surgery- and hardware-related AEs, including intracranial haemorrhage |
| Halpern et al., [33] 2019 | A controlled multicenter prospective trial | 3-year follow-up of a controlled multicenter prospective trial | Measured scores remained improved from baseline to 36 months on CRST. Range of improvement from baseline was 38%–50% in hand tremor, 43%–56% in disability, 50%–75% in postural tremor, and 27%–42% in QOL |
| Park et al., [38] 2019 | Retrospective study | Intractable ET tremor patients treated with MRgFUS thalamotomy for ET | 4 years postoperatively, improvement of the hand tremor score was 56%, disability score was 63%, postural score was 70%, and action score was 63%. There was no permanent adverse effect throughout the 4-year follow-up period |
| Sinai et al., [39] 2020 | Prospective study | 44 ET patients treated with unilateral MRgFUS VIM thalamotomy over 5 years | Tremor was significantly improved immediately following MRgFUS in all patients. |
| CRST scores in the treated hand improved by a median of 23 at 5 years. QUEST scores showed significant improvement, with median change of 28 points at 5 years | |||
| Paschen et al., [87] 2019 | Prospective study | 20 patients with ET with DBS | VIM-DBS improved the TRS in the short term and long term significantly. Long-term worsening of the TRS was more profound during stim-ON than in the stim-OFF condition, indicating habituation to stimulation |
| Gallay et al., [61] 2020 | Prospective study | Unilateral MRgFUS on ten chronic therapy-resistant ET patients | Reduction in CRST score at 3 months. No bleeding or infection. No dysarthria |
| Martínez-Fernández et al., [54] 2020 | Retrospective study | 9 patients with refractory ET and previously treated with unilateral FUS thalamotomy at least 5 months before underwent bilateral treatment | 9 patients were treated. No permanent AEs. CRST score improved by 71%, reduction in head and voice tremor was 66% |
| Ito et al., [37] 2020 | Prospective study | 10 ET patients who underwent MRgFUS left-sided VIM thalamotomy | 60% decrease in the average CRST score of the right hand persisted until 2 years. CRST score of the left hand and the average QUEST score showed no improvement. Headache was the most common AE no delayed Aes |
| Iorio-Morin et al., [88] 2021 | Prospective, single-arm, single-blinded phase two trial of second-side magnetic resonance | Guided FUS thalamotomy in patients with ET | Improvement in QOL at 3 months. Tremor significantly improved in all patients |
| Fukutome et al., [84] 2022 | Retrospectively study | Study of efficacy and safety of staged bilateral VIM thalamotomy for refractory ET | Progressive reduction of CRST total scores from baseline to second postop review |
| Cosgrove et al., [29] 2023 | Prospective, controlled, multicenter clinical trial | The long-term safety and efficacy of unilateral MRgFUS thalamotomy for medication-refractory ET in a cohort of patients | CRST scores for postural tremor (Part A) for the treated hand remained significantly improved. Combined hand tremor/motor scores (Parts A and B) also improved by 49.5% and 40.4% |
| Kaplitt et al., [89] 2024 | Prospective, open-label study | Bilateral FUS thalmatomy on ET | Tremor/motor score improved from 17.4 to 6.4. Significant improvement in mean (SD) postural tremor and mean (SD) disability score 12 developed- ataxia, 6 persisted at 12 months |
| Hino et al., [35] 2024 | Retrospective study | Real-world data from 101 patients who underwent MRgFUS between July 2019 and March 2022 at a single institution were analyzed | MRgFUS significantly improved total CRST and tremor score across all SDR subgroups. Additionally, there were no significant differences in the improvement rates among the 4 subgroups |
| Saporito et al., [90] 2024 | Prospective evaluation | Cognitive and neurobehavioral profile of patients with ET or PD related tremor undergoing MRgFUS thalamotomy at 1 year-follow-up following the treatment | Significant improvement was detected at the 1 year-follow-up assessment in anxiety and mood feelings (Hamilton Anxiety rating scale); Beck depression Inventory II score |
| Author, year | Type of study | Design | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mitchell et al., [91] 1989 | Animal case control study | Induced generalized parkinsonism vs. unilateral parkinsonism studied on monkeys | The central importance of the STN in all three conditions is proposed, and supportive evidence for the excitatory nature of subthalamic efferent fibres is adduced |
| Bergman et al., [49] 1990 | Experimental animal study | Artificially induced parkinsonism studied on monkeys | Significant role of excessive activity in the STN in PD |
| Guridi et al., [50] 1996 | Experimental animal case control study | 9 monkeys treated with MPTP in which the STN was unilaterally lesioned by kainic acid injection | Significant role in role of STN hyperactivity in the pathophysiology of parkinsonism and may have surgical implications |
| Alvarez et al., [92] 2005 | Open label pilot study | Patients with staged subthalamotomy compared to 11 patients received bilateral simultaneous subthalamotomy | Bilateral subthalamotomy may induce a significant and long-lasting improvement of advanced PD |
| Alvarez et al., [51] 2009 | Prospective study | 89 patients with PD were treated with unilateral subthalamotomyand followed up | Unilateral subthalamotomy was associated with significant and sustained motor benefit |
| Na et al., [42] 2015 | Case report | Study of unilateral MRgFUS pallidotomy in a patient with PD | Unilateral MRgFUS controls levodopa-induced dyskinesia and cardinal motor symptoms |
| Schlesinger et al., [43] 2015 | Prospective study | 7 PD patients, with severe refractory tremor, underwent VIM thalamotomy using MRgFUS | Thalamotomy using MRgFUS is safe and effective in PD patients |
| Bond et al., [44] 2017 | Randomized controled study | 53 patients underwent FUS thalamotomy or a sham procedure at 2 centers from October18, 2012, to January 8, 2015 were studied | FUS thalamotomy for patients with TDPD demonstrated improvements in medication-refractory tremor by CRST assessments |
| Zaaroor et al., [40] 2018 | Prospective study | Patients with severe medication-resistant tremor who underwent unilateral VIM thalamotomy using MRgFUS | MRgFUS created a lesion at the planned target in all patients, resulting in significant relief of symptoms |
| Martínez-Fernández et al., [53] 2018 | Prospective, open-label pilot study | 10 patients with asymmetric parkinsonism underwent FUS unilateral subthalamotomy | MRgFUS unilateral subthalamotomy was well tolerated and improved motor features |
| Jung et al., [58] 2019 | Prospective, nonrandomized, single-arm clinical trial | 10 patients with medication-refractory, dyskinesia-dominant PD underwent unilateral MRgFUS pallidotomy using the Exablate 4,000 device | Demonstrated the efficacy of pallidal lesioning using MRgFUS and certain limitations that are unavoidably associated with incomplete thermal lesioning due to technical issues |
| Eisenberg et al., [59] 2021 | Multicentre open-label study | 20 patients with PD and L-dopa responsiveness, asymmetrical motor signs, and motor fluctuations, including dyskinesias, underwent unilateral MRgFUS ablation of the globus pallidus internus | MRgFUS pallidotomy is feasible and effective in the treatment of patients with PD and motor fluctuations, including dyskinesias |
| Polyakova et al., [48] 2020 | Experimental animal study | 2 male Japanese monkeys were studied for recording of STN neuronal activity was performed 2 or 3 d/week for several months | The STN, receives cortical inputs through the cortico-STN direct and cortico-striato-external pallido-STN indirect pathways |
| Martínez-Fernández et al., [54] 2020 | Randomized control study | 40 enrolled patients, 27 were assigned to FUS subthalamotomy (active treatment) and 13 to the sham procedure (control) | FUS subthalamotomy in one hemisphere improved motor features of PD |
| Gallay et al., [61] 2020 | Case series | 52 interventions in 47 patients | Significant reduction in UPDRS |
| Gallay et al., [23] 2021 | Prospective study | 10 patients suffering from chronic and therapy-resistant PD having received bilateral PTT were followed for 1 year after operation of the second side | UPDRS reduced by 52%. Gait and postural instability unchanged. Speech difficulties increased |
| Armengou Garcia et al., [55] 2021 | Prospective study | 14 patients underwent unilateral MRgFUS subthalamotomy were studied | MRgFUS is safe and that the benefits on PD motor features are similar to what was previously reported |
| Yamamoto et al., [46] 2021 | Prospective study | 1-year outcomes of VIM thalamotomy with FUS in patients with medication resistant TDPD | VIM-FUS thalamotomy can be safely and effectively used to treat patients with TDPD |
| Sinai et al., [41] 2022 | Retrospective study | Outcome of FUS thalamotomy in TDPD patients with 1–5 years of follow-up | CRST score, median UPDRS score, decreased significantly Adverse events were mild |
| Krishna et al., [60] 2023 | Randomized controlled study | 94 patients, 69 on active treatment were studied | Unilateral pallidal ultrasound ablation improved motor function or |
MRgFUS, magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound; ET, essential tremor; DBS, deep brain stimulation; ETRS, essential tremor rating score; CCT, cerebellothalamic tractotomy; HF, hand function; FUS, focused ultrasound; EQ-5D, EuroQol-5 dimension; VIM, ventral intermediate nucleus; UPDRS, Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale; QUEST, Quality of Life in Essential Tremor Questionnaire; PD, Parkinson’s disease; QOL, quality of life; AE, adverse event; CRST, Clinical Rating Scale for Tremor; TRS, tremor rating scale; SD, standard deviation; SDR, skull density ratio.
MRgFUS, magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound; PD, Parkinson’s disease; STN, subthalamic nucleus; MPTP, 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine; FUS, focused ultrasound; TDPD, tremor-dominant Parkinson’s disease; CRST, Clinical Rating Scale for Tremor; VIM, ventral intermediate nucleus; UPDRS, Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale.
